Really nice! Everyone was friendly and I was seated quickly. Food was exactly what I needed and the drinks where well made.
Absolutely disappointed!! Will not frequent this location!! Came in to order a beer, appetizer and two pizzas to do. Mid afternoon, two or three tables occupied in the main dining room and bar seating about half full. Ordered Italian Nachos, lemonade for kid and a small beet sampler to see what I wanted. Nachos came out about 25 minutes later, lemonade followed and still no beer sample (evidently the bar was still working on it, yet two people behind the bar were not busy). Finally got a sample and server finally stopped long enough to take to go order. Beer came out 10 minutes later and pizza followed as not to go. Had them go package them to go as originally requested. Brought to servers attention that nachos were super greasy and the marinara tastes like tomato paste. She says it's just basic pizza sauce and that's all they have. Eventually got the check and that took another 20 - 25 minutes. There was no hustling, just lolly gagging along. On the way out I professionally expressed my displeasure with a to go order experience taking over an hour and a half. She apologized and said she had no excuse but acknowledged the kitchen was definitely slow. This wasn't a kitchen issue (although the Italian Nachos were terrible). So disappointing to see where service levels have gone.
Deep dish Pepperoni/jalapeno. We had to settle for jalapeno because there was No NM Green Chili. Very disappointing. Pizza was good but if ur gona have green chili as an ingredient on ur menu, u should have it available. It's available in NM😁 Good service, good pizza.
Pizza: was pizza Pretzel sticks with beer cheese was delicious Salad: well, salad is salad. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs. The pasta and sauce was okay. But, the meatballs were completely inedible. They were burnt, I couldn’t bite into them because they were hard as a rock. Honestly, there are better places to eat, that is better on your wallet!
December 30, 2023 @8:00PM We've come to this Old Chicago several times. I like the food but haven't always had the best experience with service. Last night we wanted to give it one last chance and I am glad that we did. We decided to sit in the cocktail/bar area and as usual the food was good but this time the service was excellent. Our server, Felicia, went above and beyond my expectations. She not only ensured the accuracy of our order but had a great personality and sense of humor. She kept our table laughing the entire evening. Thank you for restoring our faith in Old Chicago’s! We will come back often and when we do, we’ll be asking for Felicia.
For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!